Listen to an AI audio recording of this newsletter

We ate a big salad outside under one of Seattle’s rare, brilliant blue skies. My friend ​Chris Hare​, an expert in the science of storytelling, had invited a fascinating group of new friends from companies including Microsoft, Costco and Amazon over for a housewarming dinner. The lettuce and tomatoes had come straight from the garden, both at their peak.

Chris told me the garden would soon move into kale and rosemary season. What thrives now will not necessarily thrive next. Good gardeners understand those cycles. They know when to plant, when to nurture, when to harvest and when conditions are telling them to wait.

The same is true for companies.

Markets move. Customer expectations rise. Competitors redefine what is possible. A company that stops looking for growth eventually gives someone else the opportunity to define the future.

But the pressure to grow can also be deceptive. A strong quarter or successful launch creates confidence. New markets look attractive. Leaders see opportunities to add products, geographies or capabilities. The natural instinct is to do more.

The problem is that favorable conditions do not last forever, and success in one season does not guarantee readiness for the next.

A good move at the wrong time can become a bad move.

Expansion brings complexity with it. In a company of 500 people or more, nearly every significant move creates new dependencies across functions, systems, incentives, talent and capital. An opportunity may look attractive on its own while still placing more strain on the organization than it can absorb.

That is why the question is not simply whether an opportunity exists. It is whether the organization is ready to pursue it.

Growth has seasons. Strategy means recognizing which one you are in.

Knowing When the Season Has Changed

​Adobe​ offers a useful example. As creation moved from desktop software toward cloud-connected and mobile experiences, Adobe launched ​Creative Cloud​ in 2012. It began building a subscription business while its traditional model still produced substantial revenue. The company did not wait until the market shifted. It entered the new one early enough to learn.

​Rent the Runway​, by contrast, invested in “clothing as a service” before the season was upon it. It proved there was a market but continues to struggle to make the model profitable. ​Urban Outfitters​, however, waited for the right conditions. It then entered the clothing rental business, with ​Nuuly​, and grew it into a $400M, profitable business that helped drive its stock price up nearly 300%.

Success depends not only on the idea, but on the timing of acting on the idea. Knowing when to move and when to hold. Or as Kenny Rogers put it, “You’ve got to know when to hold ’em; Know when to fold ’em; Know when to walk away; Know when to run.”

When to Move

#1 The Window is Opening

The signs of a window opening at first appear small. You understand why customers are choosing the innovation and can forecast what will happen if they demand grows.

​Coach​ illustrates the difference. Under ​Lew Frankfort​, who we interviewed for our ​Outthinkers podcast​, the company clarified its position around accessible luxury, learned deeply from customers and built repeatable direct-to-consumer capabilities before taking the brand global. Lew committed himself to the company because he saw the signs that customers were intensely loyal to the brand. Sales grew from roughly $6 million to $5 billion.

#2 Scale Will Strengthen Your Model

The best expansion does more than add revenue. It improves the strategic strength of the enterprise.

Before you scale, be sure getting bigger will actually make the business stronger. As physicist ​Geoffrey West​ shows in ​Scale​, when an organism grows, the systems needed to support it do not all grow at the same rate.

Businesses behave similarly. If acquiring each new customer costs more than that customer generates, or each new market adds more complexity than profit, growth magnifies the weakness. Scale should improve your economics, not simply multiply them.

Ask: Will the move make the organization faster at learning, better at responding, or more profitable?

#3 Waiting Is Becoming the Bigger Risk

Sometimes speed itself creates advantage. In ​Blitzscaling​, LinkedIn cofounder ​Reid Hoffman​ and entrepreneur ​Chris Yeh​ argue that when markets exhibit winner-take-most dynamics, companies may need to prioritize speed over efficiency. Network effects, switching costs or emerging standards can make an early lead increasingly difficult for competitors to overcome.

In these situations, waiting for certainty can be more dangerous than moving with imperfect information. The question is not simply whether an opportunity is attractive, but whether delaying will make the position significantly harder, or more expensive, to capture later.

When the window is closing, scale before someone else closes it.

When to Hold

#1 Growth Is Masking a Weaker Core

Companies often expand because the core has stopped producing obvious growth. But adding a market or product does not resolve the fundamental flaw of the business. It can distract investors who are fixated on the top line.

As ​Pete Fader​, co-author of my next book, often shows through his work, trying to grow your way out of a bad business just compounds the problem and can lead to disaster. He was able to predict the stock price of one company would crater because they were losing valuable customers and replacing them with less valuable (i.e., less loyal) ones.

When leaders cannot explain why the unit economics are working, the organization has not earned the right to replicate itself.

Expansion should not become an escape from the harder work of strengthening the business the company already has.

#2 Momentum Is Outrunning Evidence

Momentum is emotionally persuasive. After a win, teams become more willing to believe the next move will work. Leaders begin interpreting enthusiasm as validation.

But a successful first move may reflect timing, novelty, one exceptional customer or a temporary market condition. Before expanding again, ask whether you have discovered a repeatable advantage or are enjoying the afterglow of a lucky decision.

The danger is allowing optimism to determine the size and speed of the bet. This is like the gambler who pulls the lever on a particular slot machine, gets the positive reinforcement of coins clinking down, and then reaches for that same lever again. You have to understand WHY the bet worked.

#3 The Organization Cannot Absorb More

A company can have the capital, opportunity and executive support to expand while still lacking organizational capacity.

​Target​’s entry into Canada is a stark example. The retailer planned 124 store openings across the country in 2013. The scale of the launch magnified inventory, supply-chain and operating problems before the model had stabilized. Less than two years later, Target announced it would discontinue its Canadian operations.

Expansion under these conditions often looks like busyness before it looks like failure.

Priorities multiply. Resources fragment. Integrators become overloaded. Decisions repeatedly rise to the executive team because no one else has the authority, information or context to make them.

The company may still be moving, but it is no longer moving coherently.

Earn the Next Move

The question is not whether the company can expand. Most large organizations can fund one more initiative.

The better question is what must be true for expansion to strengthen the system rather than burden it.

Move when the window is opening, when scaling will strengthen your business model, and/or when waiting is too big a risk. Hold when expansion is compensating for a weak business model (think unit economics), when emotion from your recent momentum is clouding evidence, or when the organization cannot absorb another layer of complexity.

The best companies are not always the fastest to grow. They are the best at matching the pace of commitment to the quality of what they know.

That is how growth remains strategic instead of becoming merely larger.

Learn to recognize when it is truly a season to scale and which opportunities are worth pursuing by joining ​Outthinker​ today.